T-19.II

Sin versus Error

Chapter 19 — The Attainment of Peace

By redefining sin as a correctable error, the section undoes the ego’s need for guilt and punishment and reorients relationships toward innocence and true choice.

Practice with this section Read the source text at acim.org/acim/en

21

of 68

Motifs

intersect here

Motif Contents

21 occurrences

Primary

Sin / Error ▲ Milestone Salvation rests on one distinction: condemnation or correction.

Pillar

Ego Sin becomes sacred when the ego turns error into religion. Guilt When sin is real, guilt is inevitable; let error be corrected.

Supporting

Sinlessness Mistake is not sin: misperception cannot make guilt real. Punishment If sin is real, punishment seems “correction”—a madness. Attack Sin assumes minds can truly attack; error can be corrected without punishment. Guiltlessness Sin becomes error: real guilt cannot be established. Authority Problem Sin as usurpation: the fantasy of changing God’s creation. Changelessness Sin cannot make real change; creation remains eternally innocent.

Minor

Defenses The ego fortifies sin like a sacred citadel to survive. Illusions Sin is the grand illusion; error is the door out. Innocence Expose the ego’s inversion that calls innocence arrogance. Judgment When sin is treated as real, it becomes the standard that judges everything. Salvation Call it error, not sin; correction makes escape and salvation possible. Body A world of bodies makes corruption seem inevitable. Death / Suffering If sin were real, immortality would die—so the premise collapses. Decision Choose your standard: condemn as sin, or correct as mistake.

Echo

Faith Replace faith in sin with faith that mistakes can be corrected. Temptation Ego tempts you to call it sin—call it a mistake instead and be free. Special Relationship Special bonds defend sin by keeping guilt protected and personal. Will of God Sin would mean defeating God’s Will—so it cannot be real.